April 12, 2011

Church Membership

This past weekend my wife and I enjoyed a wonderful meal with a couple that is relatively new to our church. Like most of those first time dinners go, we talked about a host of things including family, hobbies, work, and of course church life and ministry. It was a wonderful time and I even violated my self imposed Saturday night curfew just to enjoy a few extra minutes of fellowship. During the course of the conversation, one of the questions that I was asked related to church membership and why I believe it to be important.

Now before I give you my response, let me first anticipate an objection. Over the years it has been pointed out to me on more than one occasion that church membership is not in the Bible. That is true to a degree. While we have no biblical account of someone joining a church as is typically done today, people were connected to a local body of believers. Most of the New Testament is written to believers in specific cities/churches such as Corinth, Thessalonica, and Ephesus. In reality, we have very few instances of unconnected believers.

I would also point out that while the process of being connected with a specific church via membership probably has little resemblance to what the church does today; Christianity in the first century was also vastly different. Back then there simply was little casual Christianity. What I mean by that is that for those who followed Christ there was often a cost. Those who came to Christ often lost their families, their jobs, and their property. With the price of discipleship so high, people did not join the church because it was the socially or culturally acceptable thing to do. In Acts 5, after God brings judgment upon Ananias and Sapphira for lying about their giving, we read these words in verses 12 and 13,
“Now many signs and wonders were regularly done among the people by the hands of the apostles. And they were all together in Solomon’s Portico. None of the rest dared join them, but the people held them in high esteem.” Did you catch that in verse 13? “None of the rest dared join them.” With a God who was serious about sin and obedience, people weren’t knocking down the doors to join the church. The cost for many was simply too high.

Today, especially in the United States, we live in a different world. Church, and I use that world very broadly, is often the acceptable thing to do. For many people church is a place not only to worship God, but also to make friends, find a mate, and build business contacts. While those things aren’t necessarily bad, the point I’m trying to make is that often the church is filled with people who aren’t that serious or even interested in following Christ. With the possibility of unbelievers in the church, people who don’t have a personal relationship with Jesus Christ, I believe the church has the responsibility to, in some way, identify those who share its beliefs and support its ministry. While the membership process can take many forms, I believe church membership is first and foremost about commitment. It is the way to identify those who want to be committed to and supportive of the church and its ministry. It is a way for people to say, “This is my place of worship. I believe what it teaches. I support what it is striving to do, and the church can count on me to be involved in and committed to what goes on here.”

Sadly, that kind of commitment is quickly fading in the American church, in my opinion. Today, many people practice, what I call, “smorgasbord church.” They go to one church for the sermon, another church for the youth group, and still another for whatever else meets their needs. Rather than supporting a specific body and ministering to the needs of others in and through that church, many seek only to satisfy and meet their own needs. People want the privileges of membership without the responsibilities of membership. This “me first” approach is a practice far different than the one prescribed by Jesus in Luke 9:23. There He described a disciple as one who denies self. Here’s the point: I believe church membership is important because it is a significant way to demonstrate commitment to and support of the work of God and the people of God.

A second reason to become a church member is to invite spiritual accountability. In Matthew 18, Jesus spells out a process in which the church comes along side those who fall into sin in order to lovingly restore them to obedient living. In my experience it is difficult, if not impossible, to bring that loving accountability to those who have not invited it through church membership. While many who are not members of the church say that they want that kind of accountability, their tune almost always changes when they are living in sin. At that point, they typically tell me I have no right to confront them and essentially tell me to get lost. By becoming a church member, you are entering into a spiritual relationship with like minded believers who are committed not simply to the church, but to Christ. You are taking responsibility to watch over your brothers and sisters in Christ and inviting them to do the same for you, even as you worship and serve together.

Do we twist peoples arm to join the church, at Harvest Bible Chapel in West Olive, Michigan? No! But we do encourage it when and where possible, including through this blog. If you are not a church member, I would invite you to prayerfully consider it. If you are a church member, be one that demonstrates your commitment through faithful support, encouragement, and service. If you approach church membership seriously, I believe you will find it a source of joy and fulfillment in your spiritual walk with Christ.

4 comments:

  1. Ken. Check the passage referred to in the second to last paragraph. I think that you meant Matthew 18, not Matthew 28.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great Topic! I've often thought that if anything should be changed about the way the American church does membership, it would be to have membership by profession. "Oh, you've been attending for 6 months and you call yourself a Christian? Then your a member now!"

    The thought that people will profess to follow Christ, will attend a church for years and never submit to their church's authority seems sad at best, sinful at worst.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Justin, might you elaborate on your comment "The thought that people will profess to follow Christ, will attend a church for years and never submit to their church's authority seems sad at best, sinful at worst."

    It seems that Jesus was understood at the time to be preaching a quickly arriving end-times. Thus when this end-times did not quickly arrive, the necessity of establishing churches became a reality (e.g. see the pseudoepigraphical letters of Titus and Timothy). However, I remain unaware of any biblical evidence that states that an individual not surrendering to the authority of a local church ought to be pitied, or worse, that this lack of surrender to a local church (as opposed to Christ) is itself a sin. Might you shed some light on your assertions for me?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anonymous-
    It has been a while, but I hope you visit this and read it again. I want to give you some meat to chew on. I don't think it is sinful (and I don't read that Jason was asserting that it is - it appears to be more of a audible pondering), but I do think Scripture absolutely gives us evidence that Christ intended for the Church to have a position of positive and empowering authority in the lives of Christians.
    (Heb. 13:17, 1 Tim. 5:17) Why does Scripture here ordain Church Leadership and require submission to it? If it's not Church Leadership, then what leadership is it refering to and does that mean we have to submit to anyone who is a Christian elder, even if they preach a perverted gospel? How do you apply these Scriptures without an understanding of Church authority? If anything, these scriptures seem to limit the abuse of authority - to that for Godly purpose, not the opposite. Remember, scripture can't mean something to us that it couldn't have meant for the original reader. Don't allow 21st century baggage to clout this holy text.
    (1 Pet. 5:1-5; also, Acts 20:29-30) In these text, how will God hold elders/shepherds accountable for those they watch over, if their is no biblical grounds for some kind of Church authority. Will God judge me as a pastor for your failure (if you have any spiritual or moral failure) even though I am not your pastor? What's the principle that makes this kind of scriptural testimony work? Second, where do these groups of people that the local worshipping body are supposed to care for come from? Are they random community or does the text indicate they belong to some organized group?
    (1 Corinthians 5:1-12) This text seems to be pretty straight forward. Is there any way that this text could be appreciated if there wasn't some form of organized body with an understanding of submission to authority somewhere?
    There is more indication of Church membership and authority in the NEw Testament, but this should suffice for your comment.
    I think the real issue is not whether the Bible talks about membership and authority in the Church, but the negative connotations that our 21st century minds react with when we see the idea come across. I do beleive that authority and knowledge have become idols for many Christians today, but that doesn't mean we simply disregard the principles clearly found in God's Word and quit striving for God-honoring application. I think we need to back up, ask what our negative baggage is bringing to our understanding of the scriptures command for authority and submission and membership, and then ask if the Bible is really saying that at all. It seems that the Biblical instruction for membership and authority structure is for the 1)The teaching of sound doctrine, 2) the edifying and exhorting of one another, and 3) the protection of the Gospel message.
    Is it a sin to not belong to a Church? I would say no. But - is the attitude behind not belonging to a church sinful? Can I suggest that it usually seems to be one of anger, pride, hurt, or a combination of all three. Scripture seems to indicate that we will be held personally accountable for the sinful manifestations of those attitudes. I think many times, those who choose not to belong to a church body or denounce church are doing so out of a sinful attitude of pride, anger, or hurt/distrust. God calls us to deal with those emotions with the help of brothers and sisters, not to separate ourselves and defiantly create something new, or avoid the issue all together.
    Please share your thoughts. God bless.

    ReplyDelete